9+ Reasons for Fault Divorce in CT: What You Need to Know


9+ Reasons for Fault Divorce in CT: What You Need to Know

In Connecticut, the authorized dissolution of marriage will be pursued primarily based on legally acknowledged transgressions throughout the conjugal relationship. This strategy requires proving that one celebration is accountable for the breakdown of the wedding as a consequence of particular actions. Examples embody adultery, abandonment, insupportable cruelty, or ordinary intemperance. The partner searching for the divorce should current proof substantiating these claims to the courtroom.

This methodology of marital dissolution can considerably affect numerous facets of the proceedings, probably affecting property division, alimony awards, and even little one custody preparations. Traditionally, it was the first pathway to divorce, reflecting societal views on marital accountability. Whereas no-fault choices exist, understanding the grounds and implications of assigning blame stays related for these searching for or defending in opposition to such claims.

The next sections will delve into the precise grounds accepted, the method of proving these grounds in courtroom, the potential affect on settlement outcomes, and comparability with different divorce pathways out there throughout the state’s authorized framework.

1. Adultery

Adultery serves as a selected and probably impactful floor for pursuing a fault-based divorce in Connecticut. Establishing adultery requires demonstrating that one partner engaged in extramarital sexual relations, thereby violating the marital vows and probably inflicting important emotional and monetary hurt. Its proof can straight have an effect on the end result of divorce proceedings.

  • Burden of Proof

    In Connecticut courts, the partner alleging adultery bears the accountability of proving its incidence. Whereas direct proof, akin to eyewitness testimony or admissions, is most well-liked, it’s usually circumstantial. Frequent types of proof embody documentation of suspicious monetary transactions, communication information, and the testimony of personal investigators. The usual of proof sometimes requires clear and convincing proof, the next threshold than the preponderance of the proof customary utilized in many civil instances.

  • Affect on Alimony

    If confirmed, adultery can affect alimony awards. Connecticut Normal Statutes enable courts to contemplate the causes for the dissolution of the wedding when figuring out alimony. A discovering of adultery might lead a courtroom to award a larger share of property or a bigger alimony cost to the wronged partner, significantly if the adulterous conduct led to monetary depletion of marital property.

  • Relevance to Property Division

    Adultery, in and of itself, would not robotically assure a disproportionate distribution of marital property. Nevertheless, if the adulterous partner used marital property to facilitate or conceal the affair (e.g., spending marital funds on items or journey for the paramour), the courtroom might contemplate this a dissipation of marital property. In such situations, the courtroom might order a redistribution of property to compensate the wronged partner.

  • Defenses Towards Allegations

    A partner accused of adultery has a number of potential defenses. One widespread protection is recrimination, the place the accused partner alleges that the opposite partner additionally dedicated adultery. One other protection includes demonstrating condonation, which means the accusing partner knew concerning the adultery however forgave it and continued the conjugal relationship. The statute of limitations additionally applies; an motion for divorce primarily based on adultery have to be introduced inside an inexpensive time after the invention of the infidelity.

Finally, the affect of adultery on a divorce case in Connecticut relies on the precise information, the energy of the proof offered, and the decide’s interpretation of the related legal guidelines. Efficiently proving adultery can have important ramifications for monetary outcomes, nevertheless it requires cautious preparation and a radical understanding of the authorized requirements concerned.

2. Abandonment

Abandonment constitutes a legally acknowledged floor for pursuing a fault-based divorce in Connecticut. It signifies a deliberate and sustained withdrawal from the conjugal relationship by one partner, thereby creating grounds for the opposite partner to hunt dissolution primarily based on the fault of the abandoning celebration. The authorized definition and situations surrounding abandonment are vital in figuring out the viability of such a declare.

  • Definition and Period

    In Connecticut, abandonment typically requires a voluntary separation from the marital house by one partner with the intent to completely terminate the conjugal relationship, with out the consent or justification of the opposite partner. Crucially, this separation should persist for a steady interval of no less than one 12 months to qualify as authorized grounds for divorce primarily based on fault.

  • Intent to Terminate the Marriage

    A key component in establishing abandonment is proving the abandoning partner’s intent to finish the wedding completely. This intent will be demonstrated by numerous types of proof, together with express statements made by the abandoning partner, their institution of a brand new residence or relationship, or their failure to offer monetary or emotional help to the deserted partner.

  • Lack of Consent or Justification

    For abandonment to be legitimate as grounds for divorce, the separation should happen with out the consent or justification of the deserted partner. If the separation was mutually agreed upon, or if the abandoning partner had a reliable cause for leaving (akin to documented abuse or threats), the declare of abandonment might not be profitable.

  • Monetary and Emotional Affect

    The affect of abandonment extends past the bodily separation. The deserted partner might undergo important monetary and emotional misery on account of the opposite partner’s departure. This misery can affect the courtroom’s selections relating to alimony, property division, and different facets of the divorce proceedings, probably favoring the deserted partner.

The profitable assertion of abandonment as grounds for a fault-based divorce hinges on the excellent presentation of proof that satisfies the stringent authorized necessities. This contains demonstrating the intent to terminate the wedding, the absence of consent or justification, and the length of the separation. Whereas the emotional and monetary impacts aren’t direct parts for the grounding of the divorce, they do have a excessive impact. Understanding these aspects is important for each these searching for to file for divorce on the idea of abandonment and people defending in opposition to such claims in Connecticut courts.

3. Insupportable Cruelty

Insupportable cruelty represents a major floor for pursuing a fault-based divorce in Connecticut. It acknowledges that sure behaviors, whereas not essentially bodily abuse, can create a marital surroundings so detrimental that it renders the continuation of the wedding unimaginable.

  • Definition and Scope

    Insupportable cruelty encompasses a variety of behaviors that inflict emotional misery, psychological anguish, or undermine the well-being of a partner. This may embody verbal abuse, fixed belittling, controlling conduct, unreasonable calls for, or different actions that severely harm the conjugal relationship. The conduct have to be demonstrably dangerous and chronic, not merely remoted incidents of disagreement or battle.

  • Subjective vs. Goal Normal

    Whereas the courtroom considers the subjective affect of the conduct on the complaining partner, there may be additionally a component of goal reasonableness. The conduct have to be thought of insupportable by an inexpensive individual in related circumstances. The courtroom assesses the frequency, severity, and nature of the conduct to find out whether or not it meets the edge for insupportable cruelty.

  • Proof and Proof

    Establishing insupportable cruelty requires presenting credible proof to the courtroom. This proof can embody private testimony from the complaining partner, corroborating testimony from witnesses (akin to mates, members of the family, or therapists), documentation of abusive or controlling conduct (e.g., emails, texts), and proof of the emotional misery suffered (e.g., medical information, remedy notes). Detailed and particular examples are essential for demonstrating the sample and severity of the conduct.

  • Affect on Divorce Outcomes

    A discovering of insupportable cruelty can affect numerous facets of the divorce settlement. Whereas Connecticut follows equitable distribution rules, the courtroom might contemplate the causes for the dissolution of the wedding when figuring out alimony, property division, and different issues. If one partner’s insupportable cruelty considerably contributed to the breakdown of the wedding or led to monetary hardship for the opposite partner, the courtroom might award a larger share of property or greater alimony funds to the wronged partner.

The profitable assertion of insupportable cruelty as grounds for a fault-based divorce requires demonstrating a transparent and convincing sample of conduct that renders the continuation of the wedding insufferable. The courtroom fastidiously weighs the proof offered and considers the general affect of the conduct on the complaining partner’s well-being when making its willpower.

4. Recurring Intemperance

In Connecticut, ordinary intemperance serves as a legally acknowledged floor for a fault-based divorce. This floor pertains to a partner’s persistent and uncontrolled use of alcohol or medication, resulting in a breakdown within the conjugal relationship. The situation have to be power and disruptive, not merely occasional situations of overindulgence. Establishing a causal hyperlink between the intemperance and the deterioration of the marital bond is essential for efficiently invoking this floor. For instance, if one partner’s constant alcohol abuse ends in neglect of familial obligations, monetary instability, or abusive conduct, the opposite partner might search a divorce primarily based on ordinary intemperance. The significance lies in recognizing that substance abuse can basically undermine the soundness and well-being of a wedding, offering a authorized foundation for dissolution the place different treatments have failed.

The sensible utility of this divorce floor requires cautious documentation and presentation of proof. Testimony from witnesses, information of arrests or therapy, and documentation of economic instability or neglect ensuing from the intemperance are all vital. Connecticut courts assess the frequency, severity, and affect of the intemperance on the conjugal relationship. A single incident or a interval of sobriety may weaken the declare. Nevertheless, a documented sample of abuse, dereliction of duties, or monetary break straight attributable to the intemperance strengthens the case significantly. As an example, if a partner persistently makes use of marital funds to gas a drug habit, leaving the household with unpaid payments and going through eviction, this presents a powerful case for establishing ordinary intemperance.

In abstract, ordinary intemperance as a floor for a fault-based divorce acknowledges the harmful potential of power substance abuse inside a wedding. Profitable utility of this floor calls for a transparent and convincing demonstration of the intemperance’s persistence, its detrimental results on the conjugal relationship, and its direct connection to the breakdown of the wedding. Whereas proving this floor will be difficult, it provides a authorized avenue for people trapped in marriages destabilized by the results of unchecked substance abuse, significantly when different interventions have confirmed ineffective.

5. Proving the fault

In Connecticut, pursuing a divorce primarily based on fault necessitates the presentation of compelling proof to substantiate the alleged misconduct. The act of proving the fault will not be merely a procedural requirement; it kinds the cornerstone of a fault-based divorce. With out ample and credible proof, the divorce motion predicated on fault will seemingly fail. For instance, if a partner claims adultery as the idea for divorce, that partner should furnish proof, akin to eyewitness testimony, documentation of suspicious monetary transactions, or admissions from the adulterous celebration, to persuade the courtroom of the infidelity. The connection, due to this fact, is causal: the power to show the fault straight determines the success of a divorce continuing predicated on particular marital misconduct.

The significance of proving the fault extends past merely securing a divorce decree. The institution of fault can considerably affect the courtroom’s selections relating to alimony, property division, and even little one custody preparations. A partner who efficiently proves that the opposite engaged in egregious misconduct, akin to ordinary substance abuse or egregious cruelty, could also be awarded a bigger share of marital property or extra favorable alimony phrases. Conversely, failing to adequately show the fault might end in a much less advantageous end result for the complaining celebration. Contemplate a case the place one partner alleges insupportable cruelty. If that partner can’t show a sample of abusive or demeaning conduct by testimony, documented communications, or corroborating proof, the courtroom might disregard the allegation, and the divorce will proceed with out contemplating the fault within the monetary or custodial determinations. This demonstrates the sensible significance of understanding the evidentiary necessities and the potential ramifications of failing to fulfill them.

In conclusion, proving the fault is an indispensable part of acquiring a fault-based divorce in Connecticut. It straight impacts the authorized and monetary outcomes of the divorce proceedings. The problem lies in gathering and presenting persuasive proof that meets the courtroom’s evidentiary requirements. The lack to adequately substantiate the claims of fault not solely jeopardizes the divorce motion itself, nevertheless it additionally diminishes the potential for a extra favorable settlement relating to property division, alimony, and little one custody. Due to this fact, anybody considering a fault-based divorce should meticulously put together their case with a deal with successfully proving the alleged marital misconduct.

6. Affect on Alimony

In Connecticut’s authorized framework, the pursuit of a fault divorce can exert a noticeable affect on the willpower of alimony. When a divorce is granted primarily based on particular fault grounds, akin to adultery or abandonment, the courtroom possesses the discretion to contemplate the transgressions of the offending partner when deciding the quantity, length, and method of alimony funds. This isn’t an computerized end result; fairly, the courtroom evaluates the totality of circumstances, together with the monetary wants and incomes capacities of each events, the size of the wedding, and the causes for the dissolution.

As an example, if one partner’s adulterous conduct led to the dissipation of marital property or brought about important emotional misery and monetary hardship for the opposite partner, the courtroom may award the next alimony cost or an extended length of help to compensate the wronged celebration. Conversely, if the fault floor is much less egregious, or if the financial disparity between the events is minimal, the affect on alimony could be much less pronounced. Contemplate a state of affairs the place one partner deserted the wedding after a protracted length. The deserted partner, having relied on the wedding for monetary stability, might obtain a bigger alimony award. But when the deserted partner possesses a excessive incomes functionality the affect will probably be rather more restricted.

The final word resolution rests with the courtroom’s judgment, making use of equitable rules to make sure a good end result primarily based on the precise information offered. The connection between fault and alimony underscores the significance of understanding the authorized ramifications of pursuing a fault-based divorce and the potential affect on the monetary settlement. People considering such motion should fastidiously assess the proof out there and search authorized counsel to navigate the complexities of the method.

7. Property Division results

Property division in Connecticut divorce instances will be considerably impacted when fault grounds are alleged. Whereas Connecticut adheres to the precept of equitable distribution, the established fault of 1 celebration can affect how marital property are divided. The next outlines key aspects of this affect.

  • Dissipation of Property

    If one partner’s actions, constituting fault (e.g., adultery resulting in the expenditure of marital funds on an affair), outcome within the depletion of marital property, the courtroom might compensate the opposite partner by awarding them a bigger share of the remaining property. This ensures that the accountable celebration will not be penalized for the opposite’s harmful conduct.

  • Financial Penalties of Misconduct

    When fault-based conduct, akin to home violence or substance abuse, has direct financial repercussions (e.g., medical bills, lack of employment), the courtroom might contemplate these penalties when dividing property. The injured partner might obtain a larger share to offset the monetary harm brought on by the opposite’s misconduct.

  • Contribution to the Marriage

    Whereas not solely decided by fault, the courtroom assesses every partner’s contributions to the wedding, each monetary and non-financial. A partner discovered at fault might have their contributions seen in a diminished gentle, probably affecting their share of the marital property.

  • Equitable Concerns

    Connecticut regulation mandates an equitable, not essentially equal, division of property. If one partner’s actions are deemed significantly egregious, the courtroom might deviate from an equal break up to realize a fairer end result, making an allowance for the ethical culpability demonstrated by the fault grounds.

Finally, whereas Connecticut operates below equitable distribution, the presence of fault in a divorce case introduces concerns that may considerably alter the property division end result. The courtroom’s goal is to realize equity, and establishing fault can present a justification for deviating from a strictly equal division when circumstances warrant.

8. Little one Custody Concerns

The intersection of kid custody determinations and fault-based divorce proceedings in Connecticut includes a cautious balancing of authorized requirements and parental health. Whereas fault grounds might affect monetary facets of the divorce, their direct affect on little one custody hinges totally on the kid’s greatest pursuits.

  • Parental Misconduct and Kid’s Properly-being

    Cases of parental misconduct, akin to substance abuse or home violence, confirmed throughout a fault divorce can considerably affect custody selections. Courts prioritize the security and well-being of the kid, and proof of such misconduct might end in restricted or supervised visitation, and even the termination of parental rights, if the courtroom determines the guardian poses a risk to the kid’s bodily or emotional well being. A guardian repeatedly arrested for drunk driving, as an example, might face limitations on unsupervised visitation to make sure the kid’s security.

  • Adultery and Custodial Preparations

    Whereas adultery might represent grounds for a fault divorce, its direct affect on custody is mostly restricted until it demonstrably impacts the kid’s well-being. If the adulterous relationship creates an unstable or inappropriate surroundings for the kid, the courtroom might contemplate this when figuring out custody preparations. Nevertheless, the mere truth of infidelity, with out proof of hurt to the kid, is unlikely to be a major issue.

  • Affect on Co-Parenting Dynamics

    A fault divorce, by its adversarial nature, can exacerbate battle between dad and mom, making efficient co-parenting tougher. Excessive-conflict divorces can negatively affect youngsters, main courts to emphasise the significance of minimizing parental battle and prioritizing the kid’s want for a secure and supportive surroundings. Courts might order co-parenting counseling or implement particular communication protocols to mitigate the damaging results of parental battle on the kid.

  • Greatest Curiosity Normal

    Whatever the grounds for divorce, Connecticut courts adhere to the “greatest curiosity of the kid” customary when making custody determinations. This customary encompasses a wide range of elements, together with the kid’s needs (if of ample age and maturity), the kid’s relationship with every guardian, the dad and mom’ potential to offer a secure and nurturing surroundings, and the kid’s general well-being. The presence of fault grounds is only one issue the courtroom might contemplate inside this broader framework.

In conclusion, whereas fault grounds in a Connecticut divorce can not directly have an effect on little one custody concerns, the first focus stays on the kid’s greatest pursuits. Parental misconduct that straight impacts the kid’s well-being is given important weight, whereas different fault grounds might have a much less direct affect. The courtroom’s overarching aim is to make sure a secure and supportive surroundings for the kid, minimizing parental battle and maximizing alternatives for wholesome growth.

9. Different Choices Exist

In Connecticut, people considering divorce aren’t restricted to pursuing fault-based proceedings. Different pathways exist that supply totally different approaches to dissolving a wedding, every with distinct benefits and concerns relative to the complexities and potential contentiousness of creating fault.

  • No-Fault Divorce

    Connecticut regulation gives for no-fault divorce, the place neither celebration is required to show misconduct to acquire a divorce decree. The grounds for a no-fault divorce sometimes contain an irretrievable breakdown of the wedding, signifying that the conjugal relationship has deteriorated to the purpose of no return. This strategy usually reduces battle and expedites the divorce course of, because it eliminates the necessity for adversarial litigation to ascertain fault. The main focus shifts from assigning blame to resolving sensible points akin to property division and little one custody.

  • Mediation

    Mediation presents a collaborative different to conventional litigation, even throughout the context of a fault-based divorce. A impartial third-party mediator facilitates communication between the spouses, serving to them attain mutually agreeable options on numerous facets of the divorce settlement. Mediation will be significantly useful in instances involving youngsters, because it encourages dad and mom to prioritize the kid’s greatest pursuits and develop a co-parenting plan. It may also be used to handle the underlying points that led to the fault grounds, probably fostering a extra amicable decision.

  • Collaborative Divorce

    Collaborative divorce is one other different that emphasizes cooperation and problem-solving. On this course of, each spouses and their attorneys comply with work collectively to succeed in a settlement outdoors of courtroom. They decide to full transparency and data sharing, and sometimes contain different professionals, akin to monetary advisors and therapists, to offer specialised experience. This strategy will be significantly useful in advanced instances involving important property or difficult custody preparations.

  • Arbitration

    Arbitration provides a extra formal different to litigation. On this course of, a impartial arbitrator hears proof and arguments from either side and makes a binding resolution on the disputed points. Arbitration can present a quicker and cheaper decision in comparison with conventional courtroom proceedings, whereas nonetheless providing a structured and neutral course of.

These different choices provide people in Connecticut larger flexibility and management over the divorce course of. Whereas fault-based divorce could also be acceptable in sure circumstances, exploring these alternate options can result in a extra amicable, environment friendly, and cost-effective decision, finally selling the well-being of all events concerned, particularly youngsters. The selection between a fault-based divorce and these alternate options must be made in session with authorized counsel, contemplating the precise information and circumstances of every case.

Incessantly Requested Questions About Fault Divorce in CT

This part addresses widespread inquiries relating to divorce proceedings in Connecticut primarily based on fault grounds, offering readability on authorized procedures and potential implications.

Query 1: What constitutes legally acceptable fault grounds for divorce in Connecticut?

Connecticut regulation acknowledges a number of fault grounds, together with adultery, abandonment (lasting no less than one 12 months), insupportable cruelty, ordinary intemperance, fraudulent contract, imprisonment for all times as a consequence of a prison offense, and fee of any notorious crime involving a violation of conjugal responsibility and punishable by imprisonment for a interval exceeding one 12 months. These grounds have to be confirmed with ample proof to the courtroom.

Query 2: How does proving fault affect the division of marital property in Connecticut?

Whereas Connecticut adheres to equitable distribution rules, the institution of fault can affect property division. If one partner’s actions constituting fault (e.g., dissipation of property by adultery) led to the depletion of marital property, the courtroom might award a bigger share of the remaining property to the opposite partner to compensate for the loss.

Query 3: Can adultery straight affect little one custody preparations in a Connecticut divorce?

The direct affect of adultery on little one custody is proscribed until it demonstrably impacts the kid’s well-being. If the adulterous relationship creates an unstable or inappropriate surroundings, the courtroom might contemplate it. Nevertheless, the mere truth of infidelity, with out proof of hurt to the kid, is unlikely to be a major issue.

Query 4: Is it potential to pursue a no-fault divorce in Connecticut if one celebration dedicated adultery?

Sure. Connecticut permits for no-fault divorce primarily based on the irretrievable breakdown of the wedding. A partner can select to pursue this route even when the opposite partner dedicated adultery. Selecting a no-fault divorce removes the necessity to show fault and may simplify the proceedings.

Query 5: What sort of proof is often required to show ordinary intemperance as a floor for divorce in Connecticut?

Establishing ordinary intemperance usually requires presenting proof of power substance abuse, its detrimental results on the conjugal relationship, and its direct connection to the breakdown of the wedding. Acceptable proof might embody testimony from witnesses, information of arrests or therapy, and documentation of economic instability or neglect ensuing from the intemperance.

Query 6: If a partner abandons the marital house in Connecticut, how lengthy should the abandonment final to be thought of grounds for divorce?

In Connecticut, abandonment should persist for a steady interval of no less than one 12 months to qualify as authorized grounds for divorce primarily based on fault. Moreover, the abandonment have to be with out the consent or justification of the opposite partner and show an intent to terminate the conjugal relationship.

The previous questions present a foundational understanding of key concerns surrounding divorce proceedings primarily based on fault grounds in Connecticut. These solutions are meant for informational functions solely and shouldn’t be thought of authorized recommendation.

The subsequent part will delve into assets out there for these considering or present process divorce proceedings in Connecticut.

Navigating Divorce Based mostly on Fault in Connecticut

People considering divorce in Connecticut predicated on fault grounds ought to adhere to particular tips. These suggestions goal to make sure a extra structured and legally sound strategy to the dissolution course of.

Tip 1: Doc Every part Meticulously: Preserve thorough information of all incidents related to the claimed fault. This contains dates, occasions, areas, and particular particulars of occasions akin to situations of cruelty, abandonment, or monetary irregularities. Such documentation serves as essential proof in courtroom.

Tip 2: Safe Corroborating Proof: Past private testimony, collect unbiased corroboration of the alleged fault. This will likely contain acquiring witness statements, monetary information, medical studies, or communications that help the claims being made.

Tip 3: Seek the advice of with Skilled Authorized Counsel: Interact an lawyer specializing in Connecticut divorce regulation, significantly these with experience in fault-based proceedings. Authorized counsel can present steering on the energy of the case, the suitable proof to collect, and the potential outcomes.

Tip 4: Perceive the Burden of Proof: Acknowledge that the burden of proof rests on the celebration alleging fault. This implies demonstrating, by clear and convincing proof, that the opposite partner’s actions meet the authorized customary for the claimed floor for divorce.

Tip 5: Be Ready for Discovery: Anticipate the invention course of, whereby each events change info and paperwork related to the case. Reply promptly and actually to all discovery requests, as evasiveness can undermine credibility earlier than the courtroom.

Tip 6: Contemplate the Potential Affect on Youngsters: Be aware of the potential affect of a fault-based divorce on any youngsters concerned. Prioritize their well-being and contemplate different dispute decision strategies, akin to mediation, to reduce battle and foster a extra cooperative surroundings.

Tip 7: Consider the Price-Profit Ratio: Assess the potential monetary and emotional prices related to pursuing a fault-based divorce versus a no-fault divorce. Think about authorized charges, investigation bills, and the potential for extended litigation. In some instances, a no-fault divorce might provide a extra environment friendly and cost-effective decision.

The following tips spotlight the need of cautious preparation, diligent proof gathering, and sound authorized recommendation when pursuing a divorce primarily based on fault in Connecticut. By adhering to those suggestions, people can navigate the method with larger readability and enhance the probability of a good end result.

The next conclusion will summarize the data offered and supply last ideas on this matter.

Conclusion

The foregoing has explored the intricacies of fault divorce in CT, detailing the precise grounds acknowledged by Connecticut regulation, the evidentiary burdens required to substantiate such claims, and the potential affect on alimony, property division, and little one custody preparations. Whereas no-fault divorce choices provide a extra streamlined strategy, fault-based proceedings stay a viable pathway for these searching for to ascertain marital misconduct and probably affect the monetary and custodial outcomes of the dissolution.

People considering this plan of action should fastidiously weigh the potential advantages in opposition to the emotional and monetary prices. Thorough preparation, diligent proof gathering, and knowledgeable authorized counsel are paramount. Understanding the nuances of fault divorce empowers people to make knowledgeable selections and navigate the authorized course of with larger readability and confidence, no matter route it could lead. Seek the advice of with a certified authorized skilled to evaluate particular person circumstances and decide essentially the most acceptable plan of action for securing a good and equitable decision.